Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

F5-6000J3036G32GX2-TZ5NRW won't POST w/ 2 DIMMs - X870E/9950X3D2 - single DIMM works

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • F5-6000J3036G32GX2-TZ5NRW won't POST w/ 2 DIMMs - X870E/9950X3D2 - single DIMM works

    Hi all, hoping someone has seen this or is running the same combination.

    Setup:
    - Kit: Trident Z5 Neo RGB 64GB (2x32GB) DDR5-6000 CL30, F5-6000J3036G32GX2-TZ5NRW
    - CPU: Ryzen 9 9950X3D2 Dual Edition
    - Board: ASUS ROG Strix X870E-A Gaming WiFi7 Neo (kit is on the QVL for this board)
    - BIOS: tested V1002, the previous version, and the latest (AGESA 1.3.0.1d)

    What happens:
    - Each DIMM POSTs and runs on its own in A2, including with EXPO II.
    - Neither DIMM POSTs on its own in B2.
    - No two-DIMM configuration POSTs (A2+B2, A1+B1, positions swapped) at any speed, including 4800 JEDEC stock. It sits on the DRAM LED for the full 15-minute training window.

    Already tried:
    - Multiple CMOS clears, reseating DIMMs, CPU reseat, cooler pressure check
    - VSOC 1.25V, VDDIO/MC 1.40V, VDDP 0.90V, VDDG CCD 900mV / IOD 1000mV, DRAM VDD/VDDQ 1.40V
    - UCLK=MEMCLK, Memory Context Restore disabled
    - Setting EXPO on one DIMM first, then adding the second

    For what it's worth, this kit ran as a pair on a GIGABYTE X870E AORUS Master X3D ICE with a regular 9950X3D, though that system had memory-related BSODs and a Karhu error at stock.

    Questions:
    1. Is anyone running this kit (or another 2x32GB kit) in dual-DIMM on a 9950X3D2? What board and BIOS?
    2. Has anyone seen a single DIMM work in A2 but not B2 like this, and what turned out to be the cause?

    Any input appreciated. Thanks!
    Gigabyte EX58-UD5 Rev. 2.0 BIOS FD | i7 920 | CORSAIR HX Series CMPSU-750HX | Cooler Master V8 | Cooler Master HAF X | 6GB Corsair Dominator Triple Channel Memory | Intel 120GB X25-M SSD | EVGA GTX 470 | Windows 7 x64

  • #2
    If a specific DIMM slot is not working, it is usually an issue of either a damaged socket (bent pins) or with the mounting pressure of the CPU cooler (overtightened).
    Team HardwareLUXX | Show off your G.SKILL products!

    Comment


    • #3
      Originally posted by emissary42 View Post
      If a specific DIMM slot is not working, it is usually an issue of either a damaged socket (bent pins) or with the mounting pressure of the CPU cooler (overtightened).
      Thanks. I took a look and no bent pins and made sure the mount wasn't overtightened.
      Gigabyte EX58-UD5 Rev. 2.0 BIOS FD | i7 920 | CORSAIR HX Series CMPSU-750HX | Cooler Master V8 | Cooler Master HAF X | 6GB Corsair Dominator Triple Channel Memory | Intel 120GB X25-M SSD | EVGA GTX 470 | Windows 7 x64

      Comment


      • #4
        There is a very low chance the channel B memory controller of the CPU could be faulty. As rare as that may be, it can happen. Thankfully AMD should just replace it under warranty then; fairly quickly too, at least in my experience.
        Team HardwareLUXX | Show off your G.SKILL products!

        Comment


        • #5
          Originally posted by emissary42 View Post
          There is a very low chance the channel B memory controller of the CPU could be faulty. As rare as that may be, it can happen. Thankfully AMD should just replace it under warranty then; fairly quickly too, at least in my experience.
          It ended up being a bad motherboard. It wouldn't run in Dual Channel. Two sticks were only recognized in the A1 and B1 slots.

          I have a new board, ASUS ROG Crosshair X870E Glacial, BIOS 1103 and now and it works fine in Dual Channel, but now I have this issue:

          Windows crashes with MEMORY_MANAGEMENT. The bugcheck is 0x1A with first parameter 0x41792, a corrupted page table entry.

          Are there recommended BIOS settings for this kit and board? Right now I'm using the stock EXPO I. Have you seen this crash on a similar setup?

          Thanks.
          Gigabyte EX58-UD5 Rev. 2.0 BIOS FD | i7 920 | CORSAIR HX Series CMPSU-750HX | Cooler Master V8 | Cooler Master HAF X | 6GB Corsair Dominator Triple Channel Memory | Intel 120GB X25-M SSD | EVGA GTX 470 | Windows 7 x64

          Comment


          • #6
            Stock would be EXPO II actually. With EXPO I the MB ignores some of the programmed advanced timings and instead optimizes them itself.

            To rule out a defective module, test them one by one with Memtest86 in DIMM A2. If Memtest86 passes with both, you can also try to use whatever workload produced the MEMORY_MANAGEMENT crashes in Windows. Usually MemTest86 is fairly reliable, though.

            Memory errors just with 3D load can indicate a temperature issue, esp if the GPU blows it's heat in the direction of the memory modules. That is the one thing, where a riser can really come in handy, looks aside.
            Team HardwareLUXX | Show off your G.SKILL products!

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by emissary42 View Post
              Stock would be EXPO II actually. With EXPO I the MB ignores some of the programmed advanced timings and instead optimizes them itself.

              To rule out a defective module, test them one by one with Memtest86 in DIMM A2. If Memtest86 passes with both, you can also try to use whatever workload produced the MEMORY_MANAGEMENT crashes in Windows. Usually MemTest86 is fairly reliable, though.

              Memory errors just with 3D load can indicate a temperature issue, esp if the GPU blows it's heat in the direction of the memory modules. That is the one thing, where a riser can really come in handy, looks aside.
              Thanks. Set the BIOS defaults with EXPO II and both sticks passed individually in MemTest86. I also ran Karhu past 1500% without any errors. Still had another crash when the system was idle for a while (monitor didn't wake and I had to hard power down — it crashed a while before that from the minidump). I set the Power Supply Control Ide to Typical Current Idle and I'll run it idle overnight again to see if it crashes again.
              Gigabyte EX58-UD5 Rev. 2.0 BIOS FD | i7 920 | CORSAIR HX Series CMPSU-750HX | Cooler Master V8 | Cooler Master HAF X | 6GB Corsair Dominator Triple Channel Memory | Intel 120GB X25-M SSD | EVGA GTX 470 | Windows 7 x64

              Comment

              Working...
              X